The flooring you choose sets the foundation for your entire home's aesthetic. Two of the most popular options — solid hardwood and luxury vinyl plank (LVP) — each have genuine advantages. The right choice depends on your lifestyle, budget, and the specific rooms you're flooring. Here's an honest comparison from the Olive + Baxter flooring team.

The Case for Hardwood

Nothing replicates the warmth and character of real wood underfoot. Hardwood flooring has been a hallmark of quality homes for centuries, and for good reason. It adds undeniable value to your property. It can be sanded and refinished multiple times over its lifespan, which means it can last a hundred years or more with proper care. Oak, walnut, hickory, and maple each bring distinct grain patterns and color tones that develop a beautiful patina over time.

Hardwood performs best in living rooms, dining rooms, bedrooms, and hallways — areas where moisture levels are controlled. It's not ideal for basements, bathrooms, or laundry rooms where humidity and occasional water exposure are concerns.

The Case for Luxury Vinyl Plank

LVP has evolved dramatically in recent years. Today's premium luxury vinyl planks feature realistic wood-grain textures and embossing that are remarkably convincing. The key advantages are waterproof construction, superior durability against scratches and dents, and a softer feel underfoot that's easier on joints during long periods of standing.

LVP excels in kitchens, bathrooms, basements, mudrooms, and homes with pets or young children. It handles spills, pet accidents, and heavy foot traffic without damage. Installation is also faster and less disruptive than hardwood because most LVP systems use click-lock installation over existing subfloors.

Cost Comparison

Hardwood typically runs higher in both material and installation costs, though the exact difference depends on the species and grade you select. LVP offers a lower upfront cost, but keep in mind that hardwood can be refinished rather than replaced, which may make it more economical over a 30-plus-year horizon.

Our Recommendation

Many of our clients use both materials in the same home. Hardwood in the main living areas and bedrooms creates the warmth and value they want, while LVP in the kitchen, bathrooms, basement, and mudroom handles the practical demands of those spaces. The key is selecting products with complementary tones so the transition between materials feels intentional.

Because Olive + Baxter is both an interior design firm and a general contractor, our flooring specialists coordinate directly with your designer to ensure every material choice works with your cabinets, wall colors, and overall design vision. We bring samples to your home and handle everything from selection through professional installation. Schedule a flooring consultation to find the perfect combination for your home.